
Autumn is a common time for businesses to carry out performance reviews and appraisals. But how can employers make sure they are more than just a tick box exercise? The Hallidays’ HR team share how managers can get the most out of the process.
As summer comes to an end, many businesses start preparing for their annual performance reviews. Done well, appraisals provides an opportunity to recognise achievements, discuss development and agree priorities for the year ahead. However, a successful review starts with good preparation.
Prepare before the meeting
Managers should take time to review the employee’s objectives, achievements and overall performance before the meeting. Think about:
- What has gone well?
- What achievements should be recognised?
- Are there any areas for improvement?
- Is any additional training or support needed?
- What would you like the employee to achieve next?
Make sure feedback is supported by specific examples, rather than general statements.
Employees should also have an opportunity to prepare. Sharing the areas you intend to discuss in advance can help make the meeting a more open and productive conversation.
Make it a two way conversation
An appraisal shouldn’t simply be a manager telling an employee how they have performed. Give the employee an opportunity to reflect on their own performance and share their views.
Questions, such as the following can help create a more meaningful conversation and may highlight issues the manager wasn’t aware of:
- “What are you most proud of?”
- “What have you found challenging?”
- “Is there anything you need more support with?”
- “Are there any skills you’d like to develop?”
Address concerns honestly
An annual review shouldn’t be the first time an employee hears about a performance concern. Managers should provide feedback throughout the year and address issues when they arise.
If there are concerns to discuss during the review, be clear about what the issue is and provide examples. It is also important to understand why someone may be struggling. There could be training needs, workload issues, unclear expectations or other circumstances affecting their performance.
Where appropriate, employers should also consider whether reasonable adjustments may be required.
Agree clear objectives
The review should finish with a clear understanding of what happens next.
Objectives should be realistic, relevant and clear enough for both the employee and manager to understand what success looks like. The SMART approach can be useful:
- Specific – What needs to be achieved?
- Measurable – How will success be assessed?
- Achievable – Is it realistic?
- Relevant – Does it support the role and business?
- Time bound – When should it be achieved?
Don’t forget development. This could include training, mentoring, professional qualifications or opportunities to take on new responsibilities.
Keep a record
Following the meeting, make sure there is a clear record of the key points discussed and any actions agreed. This might include:
- achievements;
- areas for development;
- objectives;
- training or support required; and
- actions for the employee and manager.
The record doesn’t need to be lengthy, but it provides a useful reference point for future conversations.
Don’t wait until next autumn
Perhaps the most important point is that performance management should be an ongoing process, not an annual event. Regular one to ones and informal feedback allow managers to recognise good performance, address concerns early and provide support when it is needed.
The autumn appraisals can then be used to reflect on the year as a whole and look ahead, rather than trying to cover everything in one meeting.
A quick appraisals checklist for managers
Before your next performance review, ask yourself:
? Have I reviewed their achievements and objectives?
? Do I have specific examples to support my feedback?
? Have I recognised what they are doing well?
? Are there any concerns that need to be addressed?
? Have we discussed development and future goals?
? Are the objectives clear and achievable?
? Have we agreed what happens next?

GTA VI launch raises absenteeism fears for businesses
Expert Opinion: AI can build you a website, but a business website needs real designers and developers
Expert Opinion: Menopause support at work