
Despite estimates that an underground HS2 station at Manchester Piccadilly could cost £5 billion more than the government’s above-ground plans, business leaders from across the city-region are set to lobby for a rethink of plans for the station.
50 political and business leaders, including Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham, represented by the Downtown in Business lobby group are set to present evidence to the Department of Transport on 6th July to call for a change to designs.
The lobby group is expected to set out its evidence as to how the additional expenditure on an underground terminus for HS2 could generate additional regeneration opportunities for the local area by keeping tracks underground, improve capacity on the wider rail network long-term, and deliver an extra around third-of-a-billion pounds a year for the city-region economy.
The HS2 high-speed rail link is set to terminate at Manchester Piccadilly, and the government has set out plans for a above-ground extension to the existing station, estimated to cost £7 billion. Original plans for the station however included proposals for an underground option for the new terminus. A new report by HS2 Ltd. has detailed that these plans could total £12 billion, and cause significantly more local disruption due to the increase plant and HGV access needed for its construction.
Frank McKenna, the Group chairman and chief executive of Downtown in Business, said:
“The current plan, to deliver a surface station, will swallow up a massive chunk of city centre land that will otherwise be economically productive and support the city’s ‘levelling up’ efforts.
“Instead, we are arguing that an underground version, which will cost an additional £3 billion according to current projections, will provide £333 million a year in additional economic benefit.
“The revised proposal put forward by the Government, in my view, just cuts corners and doesn’t mirror what HS2 has been designed to achieve and makes a mockery of the levelling-up agenda.
“With an underground station, we can make the most of space and make a real difference to the future of the city and the wider region.”
Government plans have also come under criticism for a lack of future connectivity with a future East-West high-speed link, Northern Powerhouse Rail. Above-ground designs would require trains passing through the city between Liverpool and Leeds to change directions, reducing the total capacity of high-speed services as trains would need to spend longer in Manchester so drivers could travel from one end of the train to the other. An underground station however would not be limited by other structures and allow trains to pass through the station.
Downtown in Business, alongside leader of Manchester City Council, Bev Craig, Mayor Andy Burnham, and Manchester Central MP Lucy Powell, will give their evidence for alternative HS2 station plans to the Department of Transport at the House of Commons on Wednesday 6th July.
